A good part of the reason I started blogging was because I went to a history conference at a UT branch up between Dallas and Fort Worth and found that, contrary to belief, many well known academic historians have found community history projects to be invaluable because of their focus and details. Photos rated high. Photos with details rate high. Interviews with participants in events rated high. Interviews with older people rated high if you cover their experience and perspective.
- Prairie Weather


“Protest works. Just look at the proof”


The last place you will hear about the new American labor movement is in big American outlets.

Via lambert, via susie. See them, their blogrolls, Twitter hash tag #1u and just about any other outlet where citizens can get the word out.

The Coalition of Immokalee Workers (CIW)

The CIW is a community-based organization of mainly Latino, Mayan Indian and Haitian immigrants working in low-wage jobs throughout the state of Florida. Via.


Navigation
Login
Blogroll
Free MP3 sites

Be your own program director. Venture off the beaten path. Live a little.

2dopeboyz: Hip hop. (RSS)

3hive: Sharing the sharing. Free and legal MP3s from over 600 underground and undiscovered artists — new ones added daily. (RSS)

Amazon MP3 Download - Frequency: Weekly. Get the latest on Amazon MP3 music downloads - new releases, freshly ripped hits, and special deals.

Arjan writes - arjanwrites music blog. (RSS)

Audio Drums - A blog for rare, possibly overlooked, maybe forgotten gems of music with a slight emphasis on electronic and indie genres. (RSS)

Common Folk Music - A blog about music, not just folk music, but all music ranging from indie to alt-country to bluegrass, because music is for the “Common Folk”. (RSS)

Direct Current New Music - Adult pop, rock, singer/songwriters, folk, Americana, alt-country, adult alternative, soul, world music, crossover jazz and simply those artists that make us go “hmmm.”(RSS)

Discobelle.net (RSS)

FensePost - FensePost is an indie music blog based in the fertile lands between Seattle, WA and Vancouver, BC. (RSS)

Fiddlefreak Folk Music Blog - Folk, bluegrass, Celtic, and other music of the people. (RSS)

Gorilla Vs Bear (RSS)

Hillydilly: Simply Good Music. (RSS)

I Rock Cleveland: Indie Rock, College Rock, Alt Rock, Modern Rock, Cleveland Rock, and Rock. (RSS)

KEXP Song of the Day: KEXP 90.3 FM - where the music matters (RSS)

Line Of Best Fit - TLOBF.COM | Music Reviews, News, Interviews & Downloads (RSS)

Minnesota Public Radio Song of the Day: Music lovers from 89.3 The Current share songs with you each weekday. (RSS)

Muruch (RSS)

Music Like Dirt: Music in all its many forms, mp3’s, live reviews and photography. (RSS)

My Old Kentucky Blog - a music blog that parties with unicorns. (RSS)

Nah Right. (RSS)

ninebullets.net. (RSS)

Rollo & Grady: Los Angeles Music Blog, LA Music Blog (RSS)

Said the Gramophone: a music weblog (RSS)

SOULBOUNCE.COM (RSS)

Sounds Better With Reverb (RSS)

Stereogum: All the MP3s on Stereogum.com (RSS)

their bated breath (RSS)

Women of Hip Hop (RSS)


Mourn ya till I join ya

The Wheel’s Still In Spin: Focusing on new music releases and reviews of individual albums as original, fictional short stories (RSS)

A Fifty Cent Lighter & A Whiskey Buzz - This site is just a way for me to have a little fun and share a little music. I’ll highlight some of my favorite artists that I play on the radio and try to expound upon their music in ways I can’t always do on the air. (RSS)

Aminal Sound

Audiofile: Music Blog, Music Articles - Salon.com

Crossfade: The CNET music blog

GarageBand.com Folk top tracks (RSS)

GarageBand.com Hip Hop top tracks (RSS)

Flawless Hustle: Urban culture blog featuring artist interviews, music reviews, legal music downloads, street art, graffiti and more! (RSS)

Blogrolling

Reciprocation

The Jon Swift principle: “I will add anyone to my blogroll who adds me to theirs.” Email or leave a comment to let me know.

BLCKDGRD

The Hunting of the Snark



Sites participating in blogroll amnesty day

Jon Swift aka Al Weisel, may he rest in peace. Co-originator of Blogroll Amnesty Day

skippy the bush kangaroo (Co-originator of Blogroll Amnesty Day) (2012)

Vagabond Scholar (2012)
Occasional blogging, mostly of the long-form variety. Keeper of the Jon Swift Memorial Roundup (The Best Posts of the Year, Chosen by the Bloggers Themselves)

Notes From Underground (2012)

Redeye’s Front Page (2012)

Wisdom of the West (2012)

Zen Comix (2012)

pygalgia (2012)

Mikeb302000 (2012)

The Agonist (2012)

Brilliant At Breakfast (2012)

Bacon and Eggs (2012)

« This Week In Tyranny | Main | Joe Klein, radical »

Do Away With the State Secrets Privilege

According to Wikipedia the State Secrets Privilege (SSP) is “an evidentiary rule - e.g., doctor-patient, lawyer-client or priest-penitent privilege - created by United States legal precedent. The court is asked to exclude evidence from a legal case based solely on an affidavit submitted by the government stating court proceedings might disclose sensitive information which might endanger national security.” It also says its origin is based in English common law. In theory it sounds like a great idea. In practice it hasn’t worked out so well. Kevin Poulsen put it best when he wrote that cases where it’s been invoked seem “a pantheon of injustice”. There are lots of scattered cases of it through the last thirty years or so but under George W Bush we’ve had a quick succession of them to give us the chance to focus on it.

The first argument against it is that it isn’t even a law. In an example of judicial activism the usual suspects don’t get too excited about, the Supreme Court decreed it into existence in U.S. v Reynolds. It’s a judicial precedent based on custom, and if you really want to be a strict constructionist you should consider the ruling an outrageous infringement on the legislature’s prerogatives. If state secrets are so urgent and precious, let the House and the Senate pass a law concerning them and have the President sign it. What is so provocative about that? As it stands I think the courts have latitude to interpret the law and respect traditions and precedents (though not be bound by them). There are, however, a lot of people who start hyperventilating when the court does something interpreted as legislating from the bench. Those folks should be expected to oppose the SSP on fundamental belief.

I believe there’s a much more compelling argument against it, and that is the importance of transparency. We ought to believe that government is obligated to disclose what it is up to. In fact, we ought to be substantially biased in favor of it. Looking at Poulsen’s examples gives you all the idea you need about what happens when government is allowed to claim national security in order to prevent disclosure: It uses the claim to cover up embarrassing or incriminating details. In none of the examples is there an actual national interest at stake. We should proceed on the assumption that that is always the case and dispose of the whole thing. In the extremely rare cases where national security is at stake there will probably be other, more compelling issues that would allow the protection of the secrets. And in the positively microscopic percentage of cases where even that wasn’t true let me give you an analogy.

I’m in the jury box and Jack Bauer is in the dock. He Ramboed his way into Pakistan and caught Osama. Took him alive not dead because he’s a professional and wouldn’t even take bin Laden’s life needlessly. On the way back to the plane his captive let slip that he knew about a nuclear bomb somewhere in Manhattan that would explode shortly. Jack tortures the answer out of him, notifies the government, experts are rushed to the scene, the bomb is defused and the day is saved. But torture is illegal because of those darn civil liberties types and now he has to stand trial. Know what? I vote him not guilty. I suspect every jury you could convene in this country would do so as well.

The SSP is the same in that the reasons given for it are as exceedingly rare as the “ticking time bomb” scenario used to justify torture. The problem is that as with torture the SSP will inevitably be abused once it is legal, and as with torture we should consider that price unacceptably high. It is a privilege that prevents us from knowing what our government is doing, and that veil of secrecy is a very appealing tool for cover-ups in the best of circumstances. In a time where the President has an authoritarian streak it will (big hat tip Marcy Wheeler) be invoked with alarming frequency.

The point is this: You state the principle and you live by it. And when the nearly unique exceptions pop up you trust that a well-informed citizenry will understand and make allowances as needed. We have almost no secrets that require an SSP. Overturn it. We’ll be sensible about it if someone asserts it in a true national security emergency.

Reader Comments (4)

That is the point, indeed. The devolution of our civic responsibilities (for vigilance, for "making allowances as needed") onto government and away from the people began years ago as we became consumers rather than citizens. We're now at a stage how where many, many Americans "can't be bothered" by the time-consuming duties of vigilance and ratiocination. They reckon we "buy" leadership and representation. They expect government to do our thinking and oversight for us.

The same people tend to accuse socialism for eroding individual responsibility. We hardly live under socialism. Perhaps capitalism is the culprit?

December 7, 2007 | Unregistered CommenterPW

That was supposed to be "blame socialism." Oops. Fractured brain.

December 7, 2007 | Unregistered CommenterPW

And on the off chance some "unsensible" jury did find Our Hero Jack guilty, there's always a presidential pardon ready and waiting.

It's what the damn things are for.

December 8, 2007 | Unregistered CommenterJHB

Or at least a commutation.

December 8, 2007 | Registered CommenterDan

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>